The America Achieves Educator Networks works to increase the number of students who have access to and complete a quality education pathway that leads to career and life success.
America Achieves Educator Networks collaborates with schools across the nation and the globe to learn about, advance, and share promising practices to improve career readiness and life success. In April 2018, our team visited STEM School Chattanooga with other school and district leaders to learn how this public high school is taking project-based learning to the next level by explicitly designing projects to develop specific, career-ready, cross-sector competencies and leveraging Gold Standard criteria for designing project-based learning (PBL). As defined by the Buck Institute for Education, Gold Standard PBL puts student learning at the center and includes essential design project elements such as student voice and choice and authenticity. In this profile, we share what the STEM School is doing to ensure all students are prepared for life after high school.
When you walk into STEM School Chattanooga, located in southeastern Tennessee, several things immediately catch your eye: the Myers-Brigg poster with a Star Wars Character for each personality type. The classroom walls that don’t reach to the ceiling and don’t have doors, giving the building an open and spacious feel. The rubrics on display that include the definition of a skill (e.g., Critical Thinking is both the capacity to combine or synthesize existing ideas, images, or expertise in original ways…) as well as the benchmark, milestone, and capstone for the development of that skill. The colorful “FabLab” with projects in various stages of development. The inspirational quotes decorating the hallways (“One man’s magic is another man’s engineering.”). The open access to a nearby college campus, where students can work towards associate’s degrees.
These elements are visual representations of the school’s mission:
“To develop and share a new paradigm for world-class education using technology as a gateway to cultivate students' inquisitive nature, exercise innovation, think critically, and collaborate to become leaders who are self-sufficient learners with the same passion as Chattanooga's Renaissance.”
STEM School Chattanooga is a public 9-12 grades high school, though there’s potential for lower grades to be added in the future. It was founded in 2012 with 75 students and now includes 263 students from all over the district who are admitted to the school through an open lottery. Since its inception, the STEM School has established itself as a model school aimed to provide a project- and problem-based learning curriculum aligned with Tennessee's state standards. The school specifically focuses on sciences, technology, engineering, mathematics, and the arts.
Dr. Tony Donen, who serves as the school principal, is the recipient of the STEM Excellence Award from the Tennessee STEM Innovation Network and the author of two books. Donen previously worked in the engineering field, and his experiences with the private sector and industry support his passions of working with students and creating a STEM-focused school. Donen reflects, “Even when scores on state tests were improving, student outcomes were not. Kids were still dropping out of college. How could we disrupt this?”
The STEM School hopes to push its practices out to other districts to support students in authentic project-based learning that will help them develop the skills needed for success beyond high school. 100% of students at STEM Chattanooga are enrolled in college-level courses and complete a yearly project in collaboration with community businesses and organizations. In 2018, STEM School Chattanooga was among 15 schools to receive the first Tennessee STEM School designation and was recognized as having a perfect score during the application process.
“Gold Standard” project-based learning is the comprehensive, research-based model created by the Buck Institute for Education to ensure that student learning remains at the forefront. According to this model, Gold Standard project-based learning must include student learning of academic content and skill development at the center, essential design project elements (outlined in detailed on their website, linked above), and project-based teaching practices. STEM School Chattanooga aligns its project-based learning initiatives with many of the elements of the Gold Standard.
Throughout the various components of the school, STEM School Chattanooga keeps its goal for project-based learning front and center: an industry-aligned model that intentionally develops the cross-sector competencies critical for career and life success. Content-knowledge acquisition through project-based learning is highly valued, and “process skills are the number one priority,” says Donen. These skills (referred to as “process skills” by the STEM School and as “cross-sector competencies” by the Educator Networks) include collaboration, critical thinking, and innovation - the three tenets of the STEM School.
As the world becomes more and more connected, learning to work effectively with a diverse group of people is an increasingly important skill, both personally and professionally. The STEM School helps students develop this ability by having students assess their personalities using Myers-Brigg, and then purposefully grouping them with peers of distinctly different personalities and guiding them to successfully communicate, collaborate, and build empathy and understanding.
STEM School Chattanooga’s curriculum is rooted in a project-based learning philosophy. The PBL units extend throughout the school year, with each grade level experiencing a deepened focus as students progress through their high school career. Because of their project-based nature, unit plans at the school are cross-curricular; unit templates are designed to support this and foster teacher collaboration. The units are set up to support students in mastering content standards as well as process skills. All unit plans and corresponding rubrics are available on the school’s website and are designed to be transparent to students, families, and community partners.
The STEM School’s PBL curriculum units include the content standards, essential STEM issues, overview of the unit, content vocabulary, and a rubric for assessing and providing feedback on performance. The units and rubrics are posted around the school. These clear and transparent expectations help students understand the process in skills development, where they are at each point, and what they need to do to achieve mastery. The rubrics speak to the importance that STEM School Chattanooga places on skills development, as the skills are emphasized over the projects themselves. “Project-based learning itself should not be the goal. Don’t do PBL just for PBL sake,” says Donen. “The goal is student learning.”
The goal is for each student to achieve mastery in each learning target, and so grades at the STEM School are improvable. According to the school’s website, “If a student earns a grade of Basic on a particular learning target, that student can improve that grade if they are able to demonstrate a higher level of mastery. In order to do so, the student is responsible to seek out the teacher and devise a plan to improve. Every day, students will have time each day during an extended lunch time to access any teacher in the school.” Through this structure, students have increased agency in their learning. They can see where they stand and how they need to grow using the rubrics, strategically plan to improve their understanding with the support of teachers and peers, and revise and evaluate to reach their learning goals.
The FabLab, short for fabrication laboratory, is a space within STEM School Chattanooga where students can design, prototype, and test products of their yearly projects. Students gain hands-on experience and develop expertise in technology-focused tools (including computers, 3D printers, electronics workbenches, digital fabrication tools, and traditional wood shop tools) as well as develop 21st century competencies like collaboration, communication, and critical thinking. STEM School students have used the FabLab to support projects like fabricating solar array panels for outdoor classrooms, making an Arduino-based electronic garden monitoring system, and inventing a charging device for smartphones powered by swinging a door.
The student-centered model is another way that STEM School Chattanooga fosters the development of process skills. Within the classrooms at the STEM School, students develop self-sufficiency by identifying what they need to work on and completing PBL tasks at a pace that makes sense for their project. By setting up a school structure (see a sample schedule here) that offers students independence, opportunities to explore their interests, meaningful practice in resource and project management, and ownership of their learning environment, the STEM School prepares students for careers that prioritize autonomy and being creative problem-solvers.
By the time STEM School students reach the 12th grade, the problems to drive projects are no longer created by teachers or other adult partners. Students are tasked with defining a STEM-related problem and designing a solution. According to the unit plan, in order to successfully complete their projects, they have to network with professionals (Collaboration - Networking), apply expert and professional knowledge in solution development (Critical Thinking - Expert Knowledge), and use creative thinking to create something new and valuable (Innovation - Invent). The partnerships the STEM School maintains with businesses and community organizations are critical for project success.
These 12th grade projects culminate in a “shark-tank”-like activity similar to pitch meetings common to venture capital, where students develop a business plan for their solution and pitch their proposal to potential funders in the community. Says Donen about this activity, “...they've shifted to what's exciting to me? What matters to me? Let me find a problem in that area, or an issue in that area, I need to then build solutions around that. I then need to prototype those solutions, test them out, see what might be the best solution, and then I have to create a business around that solution.”
As Buck Institute’s Larmer and colleagues describe, “Authenticity is a complex concept, but it’s generally synonymous with making a learning experience as ‘real’ as possible.” STEM School Chattanooga emphasizes authenticity by connecting project-based learning to life beyond the classroom and creating projects that identify problems that pertain to local business and community needs.
Each year that they are in school, STEM School students complete one or multiple PBL projects. These projects generally require students to take their learning beyond the four walls of the school and connect with local organizations or businesses. Through these projects, students have the opportunity to explore relevant issues.
Projects in grades 9-11 are designed through teachers collaborating across subjects and connecting with industry and community partners. For example, an 11th grade PBL unit plan that emphasizes collaboration asks students to “conduct market research and prepare a user needs analysis for use of highly automated vehicles in Chattanooga.” Community and business partners in this unit include representatives from Global Institute for Urban Mobility and Urban Planning, UTC Department of Mechanical Engineering, and CARTA. According to the unit overview, “For the school partner, the focus is on capturing user needs in Chattanooga of potential users from all walks of life to support development of the Flywheels HAV (highly automated vehicle) concept. For the STEM School, the focus is on the collaboration and critical thinking skills demonstrated by the student teams.” At the conclusion of the unit, teams of students present the results of their market research and user needs analysis for HAVs in Chattanooga. They are assessed using the Chattanooga State Community College rubric for Collaborative Skills and the Association of American Colleges and Universities rubric for Critical Thinking Skills.
Students are able to learn from leaders in business and higher education, and understand how what they learn at the STEM School will be relevant in their careers and lives. By working on community projects with real impact (for example, helping to design a new public park), students feel deeper connection, ownership, and pride. At the conclusion of their projects, students create a public product that they present to their community.
What makes these partnerships so successful? “Buy-in from teachers, champions to keep the relationships strong and impactful, and a clear understanding of goals and roles,” says Nesha Evans, Director of High School Programs at Chattanooga State Community College. Evans suggests schools interested in these type of partnerships explore an advising board to analyze impact and make collective decisions. Mike Cleery, UNUM Vice President of Global Hosting and Data Services, notes that it’s important to see these partnerships as mutually beneficial; businesses must be open to what students can offer. “We should never diminish what students can bring to industry. There’s a lot of value in the way they think and the questions they ask...it’s schools like STEM School Chattanooga that will keep us competitive in the global economy.”
The school views project-based learning not as the “main thing,” but as an effective tool to help students have authentic experiences that prepare them for career and life success.
As STEM School Chattanooga continues to grow and evolve, the staff reflects on the lessons learned, including the importance building a clear vision, communicating a case for “why,” developing students’ skills to engage in PBL, and ensuring teacher buy-in.
STEM Chattanooga places high value on thinking outside the box and trusting the process. However, the staff notes, these things only work if time is taken to develop a culture that supports the effective implementation of PBL. The school has come to understand that in order to foster creativity and innovation, significant work needs to be done in the beginning.
Build a clear vision of student success and a career-ready graduate
This helps to create a strong school community through maintaining and sharing identity. A sense of belonging, ownership, and pride comes from coalescing around the common vision. Tangible elements that support the STEM School’s vision include strong mission and vision statements, the three tenets of the school’s four-year plan, shared rubrics, cross-curricular unit plans, and school-wide learning targets.
Communicate a case for “why"
A key lesson STEM School Chattanooga has discovered in its endeavors to develop and share a new paradigm for world-class education is that values must be focused on, more so than mechanics. “You have to communicate the why,” says Donen. “You cannot trust something if you don’t know why you are doing it.” Michael Stone, Director of Innovative Learning at the Chattanooga Public Education Foundation, agrees. “In the past, the mechanisms of project-based learning have been taught, not the value. The value must be emphasized - why are we doing project-based learning?”
Develop students’ skills to engage in PBL
Donen points out that a common pitfall he sees when schools implement project-based learning is starting with the task and assuming that students will understand how to go about effectively completing it. “What [schools] haven't done is set a structure within their classes of inquiry and investigation, and kids being in charge of their learning. When they jump straight into, 'here's a performance task,' but they haven't set that environment, what tends to happen is they struggle with the kids having quality products. Kids don't necessarily understand how to use that time, how to collaborate with each other, how to share ideas and find ideas, and how to ask the right questions.”
Ensure teacher buy-in
The model is student-centered, and teachers are critical to the foundation of the STEM School. They guide students, help push their thinking, offer tutoring, and facilitate the learning. Even though students are given the freedom to work on their own and take charge of their learning, resources and support from the educators at the STEM School are always available. The STEM School prides itself on its exceptional education program developed in collaboration with its teachers. Teachers are encouraged to create, connect, and bring in new ideas. “We want teachers to have the courage to create,” says Donen. “If creation is the school’s vision, then teachers should be able to create and select their own instructional strategies.”
Teachers as leaders are encouraged and valued at STEM School Chattanooga. The school found that the practice of developing teachers as leaders is most effective when the teachers who are excited and on-board with the innovative new practices are the ones who are engaged first. These teachers become champions - bringing in new ideas, supporting other teachers, and reaching out to businesses and community organizations to form partnerships.
STEM School Chattanooga is currently working to create stronger coherence and scaffolding across grade levels, so that each grade expands on the previous one. Working towards this vision, the school is beginning with the end in mind - asking what a quality senior capstone project looks like, and then planning backwards to ninth grade. Another initiative the school hopes to expand on is deepening the assessment of quality project-based learning. The STEM School puts forward the question: how can the true value, in addition to the mechanics, of project-based learning be assessed?
The STEM School is committed to its mission of developing and sharing a new paradigm for world-class education. It aims to support other schools - both nationally and globally - in implementing similar STEM-focused, project-based learning curricula. According to its website, “The STEM school will serve as a demonstration site for innovative practices in STEM education and incubate a curriculum and partnership program which can be implemented in schools throughout the region.”
While there are many promising practices, there’s no one right way to help students achieve career and life success. Says Donen, “It has been amazing to see how many different ways schools are going about trying to help students lead in their learning, become lifelong learners, and be successful in the workforce. What I've found listening and learning to the different ways is that there's not one right answer. When people come visit my school, for instance, sometimes they leave saying, ‘We want to do that.’ But [what we are doing at the STEM School] might not necessarily fit within their environment. They need to take pieces that matter to them and really build upon them...there's so many different ways that people have gone about doing it, that you can find a successful model that you can take a lot of pieces from and build off that within your school setting.”
Schedule a Tour: firstname.lastname@example.org